NRAO Home  >  Green Bank  |  Wiki Topic:    GB > PTCS > PTCSProjectPlan (r1.1 vs. r1.36)
   Changes | Index | Search | Statistics | Go
 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.36 - 07 Oct 2008 - MartyBloss)
Added:
>
>

2009 Task List

  • Release Planning
    • Content and dates for releases of the servo replacement control system and hardware
  • Test Planning
    • Test strategies, plans, and procedures



 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.35 - 30 Jun 2008 - MartyBloss)

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.34 - 31 Mar 2008 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

    • Improve the performance of the GBT's servos, includiung short- and long-term improvements
>
>

    • Improve the performance of the GBT's servos, including short- and long-term improvements

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.33 - 05 Feb 2008 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

Link to: PTCS project group meeting agenda -- 06 March 2007

>
>

PTCS Project Planning Page

Changed:
<
<

Proposed Accelerated PTCS plan

>
>

This page is intended to be the top-level page providing an overview, and links to work related to continued PTCS improvements in the areas of servo performance, pointing accuracy, collimation and small-scale surface errors.

Changed:
<
<

PTCS Project Plan

>
>

Proposed Accelerated PTCS plan

Changed:
<
<

This is intended to be the top-level page providing an overview, and links to work related to continued PTCS development. We are going to start working at a low level to improve pointing and collimation, as well as static measurements and corrections to small-scale surface accuracy.

>
>

Link to: PTCS annual group planning meeting -- 06 March 2007

Changed:
<
<

Work packages:

  • Short-Term Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)
>
>

Table of Contents:

Work packages

  • Pointing model and azimuth track analysis (Todd)
Changed:
<
<

    • OOF holography
>
>

    • gain curves
Changed:
<
<

  • Holography system (Todd)
>
>

  • Holography projects (Todd)
    • OOF holography improvements
    • Traditional holography system and strategy
Deleted:
<
<

    • What else...
Added:
>
>

2008 Task List

2007 Task List

Changed:
<
<

  • (Possibly Develop and deploy traditional holography system (existing or new during summer shutdwon, depending on investigations by Todd)
>
>

  • Develop and deploy traditional holography system
Deleted:
<
<

2007 Task List

New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)

This task is to complete design and implementation of a new analysis package for a new pointing model.

Antenna characterization and commissioning (Frank)

Coordinate and perform commissioning and characterization observations

Servo Improvements (John)

This task is to improve the performance of the GBT's servos. It includes short- and long-term improvements

Interlock upgrade (John)

This task is to replace the interlock system on the GBT with a PLC-based system for better maintainability. It is now under the Servo Improvements project.

Traditional holography project (Todd)

This task is to rebuild interface to the existing backend to support higher data rate transfers, perform lab tests on the holo receiver and redeploy it. Also perform simulations and re-examine old data.

OOF holography project (Todd)

This task is to coordinate efforts on doing OOF measurements on the GBT

LRF system (instrument development and system architecture) (John)

Coordinate the Laser Rangefinder System developments

Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (John)

Coordinate development of other miscellaneous PTCS instruments such as tippers, interferometers, etc.

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.32 - 22 Aug 2007 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

>
>


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.31 - 15 Aug 2007 - ToddHunter)
Added:
>
>

  • Entry in NRAO Five-Year plan:
    • The detailed plans for FY2008 are described in the Program Plan. The long range goals for FY2009-2012 are to deliver the critical improvements to the telescope that are required to enable efficient 3 millimeter operation, and to provide the ancillary instrumentation needed to make optimal use of the available 3 mm weather conditions in the context of dynamic scheduling. Specifically, these goals include:
      1. the reduction of the small-scale surface error of the primary reflector,
      2. improvements to the servo control systems for the primary, secondary and active surface system,
      3. fielding additional instrumentation to more accurately track the performance of the telescope and its environmental conditions
    • Having recommissioned the traditional holography receiver in FY2008, we plan to use it in FY2009 to obtain detailed maps of the surface which should allow us to derive more accurate zero point positions for the 2209 surface actuators. During FY2009-2010, we also plan to continue to develop and implement new digital servo control systems for the primary, secondary and active surface that will replace the aging and limited analog systems delivered by the contractor. These systems are now needed in order to improve the pointing and tracking performance of the telescope in non-benign conditions by enabling the use of modern, advanced servo algorithms.
    • Some of our plans for 2010-2012 are naturally contingent on the success of our efforts in preceding years. Depending on the results traditional holography, we may need to make engineering refinements to the holography system, or we may attempt further improvements to the surface via the laser range finder system that remains under development. Once the servo improvements are complete, we will focus on providing ancillary instrumentation to better track the real-time observing conditions. A multi-color tipping radiometer and a cloud monitor are two devices that would provide valuable input into the dynamic scheduling pipeline.

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.30 - 15 Aug 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

  • LRF system (instrument development and system architecture) (Steve)
>
>

  • Laser Range Finder (LRF) system (instrument development and system architecture) (Steve)
Changed:
<
<

  • Servo interlock system ( not strictly PTCS, but the same group of people are working on it
>
>

  • Servo interlock system (not strictly PTCS, but the same group of people are working on it)

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.29 - 14 Aug 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)

>
>

New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.28 - 23 Jul 2007 - ToddHunter)
Deleted:
<
<


Possible Personnel Assignments


Miscellaneous Things To Do:

Capture thoughts here, then we can transfer them to the appropriate place.


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.27 - 18 Jul 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

Holography system (Todd)

>
>

Traditional holography project (Todd)

Changed:
<
<

OOF holography system (Richard)

>
>

OOF holography project (Todd)


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.26 - 15 Jul 2007 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

Interlock upgrade (John)

This task is to replace the interlock system on the GBT with a PLC-based system for better maintainability.
>
>

Interlock upgrade (John)

This task is to replace the interlock system on the GBT with a PLC-based system for better maintainability. It is now under the Servo Improvements project.

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.25 - 05 Jul 2007 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

AcceleratedPTCSPlan

OverallPTCSProgram?

>
>

Proposed Accelerated PTCS plan

Changed:
<
<

  • New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)
>
>

  • Short-Term Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)
Deleted:
<
<

  • Interlock upgrade (John)
Changed:
<
<

  • Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (Todd)
>
>

  • PTCS instrumentation (John)
Deleted:
<
<

  • Photogrammetry (John)
Changed:
<
<

Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (Todd)

>
>

Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (John)

Changed:
<
<

Photogrammetry (John)

Coordinate the efforts to measure the surface with photogrammetry
>
>

Deleted:
<
<

  • Email Simon Radford to consider OOF for CCAT
  • Who will/will we present at URSI?
    • Kim (Pointing)
    • John (servo)
    • Ron/Roger (baselines)

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.24 - 03 Jul 2007 - JohnFord)
Added:
>
>

OverallPTCSProgram?


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.23 - 05 Jun 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

>
>

This task is to rebuild interface to the existing backend to support higher data rate transfers, perform lab tests on the holo receiver and redeploy it. Also perform simulations and re-examine old data.


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.22 - 10 May 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

    • Modification Request here
>
>


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.21 - 31 Mar 2007 - JohnFord)
Added:
>
>

AcceleratedPTCSPlan


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.20 - 26 Mar 2007 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

This task is to investigate and implement, if appropriate, a traditional Holography system for the GBT surface measurement.

>
>

  • Rebuild interface to existing backend to support higher data rate transfers
    • Modification Request here

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.19 - 06 Mar 2007 - ToddHunter)
Added:
>
>

Link to: PTCS project group meeting agenda -- 06 March 2007

Deleted:
<
<

PTCS project group meeting agenda -- 6 March 2007 -- GB137/CV311 -- (304)456-2239


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.18 - 05 Mar 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

PTCS project group meeting agenda -- 6 March 2007 -- GB137/CV311

>
>

PTCS project group meeting agenda -- 6 March 2007 -- GB137/CV311 -- (304)456-2239

Changed:
<
<

>
>

Changed:
<
<

    • a. Surface, beam pattern, and holography simulations (Fred, Todd)
>
>

    • a. Surface, beam pattern, and holography simulations (Fred, Todd) run2.ps run3b.ps

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.17 - 05 Mar 2007 - ToddHunter)
Changed:
<
<

We (John, Todd, Richard) will add timescales before January 30th project meeting

>
>

PTCS project group meeting agenda -- 6 March 2007 -- GB137/CV311

  • 1. Instruments for dynamic scheduling (Dana)
  • 2. Progress on new pointing model and track model (Kim,Todd)
  • 3. Brief summary of servo improvements & plan (John)
  • 4. Status of laser range finder prototype (Steve)
  • 5. Plans for reviving traditional holography
    • a. Surface, beam pattern, and holography simulations (Fred, Todd)
    • b. Practical issues and concerns (Todd, Ron, Steve, others) wikipage
Deleted:
<
<

Plan for a PTCS project group meeting week starting February 12th

Changed:
<
<


We should have a mini In-Progress Review (when?) to review this plan with the wider project group, and perhaps a few knowledeable outsiders. This should be rather informal however.

Work packages:

>
>

Work packages:


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.16 - 31 Jan 2007 - FrankGhigo)
Changed:
<
<

    • Near-term goal (Winter 2007/08) is to provide good performance at Q-band (52GHz), and explicitly to widen as much as possible then environmental envelope within which this performance can be delivered.
>
>

    • Near-term goal (Winter 2007/08) is to provide good performance at Q-band (52GHz), and explicitly to widen as much as possible the environmental envelope within which this performance can be delivered.

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.15 - 29 Jan 2007 - JohnFord)
Deleted:
<
<

  • Maintain PTCS Instrumentation in state of readiness: active surface, temperature sensors (structural and air), weather stations.
    • Jason Ray,J.D. Nelson
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system (LRFV2)
    • John Shelton, John Ford, Steve White, Electronics Tech, Mechanical engineering
  • Servo investigations and improvements
    • Trajectory generation
      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, Todd Hunter
    • Tracking at low azimuth rates
      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, John Ford, Todd Hunter
  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models
    • Frank Ghigo, Ron Grider, Todd Hunter
  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
    • John Ford, Tim Weadon, Bob Anderson
  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
    • Fred Schwab, Todd Hunter
  • Investigate wind measurements for corrections.
    • John Ford, Jason Ray

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.14 - 19 Jan 2007 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see PointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Confirm Kim is now responsible for processing inclinometry data
  • assume new analysis package is matlab for now, may reassess later.

* Need to significantly re-engineer the antenna manager to do correct upstream co-ordinate conversions including both the actual subreflector position and the quadrant detector indications (any other indications. Do we do this now, or after some big system redesign?

Antenna characterization and commissioning (Frank)

  • co-ordinate execution of pointing runs, servo tests, etc.
  • Need to get wiki commissioning history up to date
  • Need to really check the quality of our mapping. Make a fully sampled beam map of a Condon double, after peaking up on a calibrator say five degrees away. Check how well the observed J2000 positions of both doubles match predicted. I think this is quite a high priority task; to my knowledge GBT staff have never really checked this. Write up as a project note.

Servo Improvements (John)

  • Servo investigations and improvements
    • Trajectory generation
      • Begin investigation on why smooth trajectory does not translate into smooth antenna motion. Requires Ford, Brandt, Hunter, Weadon
    • Tracking at low azimuth rates
      • Finish this off by 2/28/07 Requires Ford, Brandt, Hunter, Weadon
    • Start a new servo system design
      • I think that we do need to redesign the servo. We can pull information from the LMT, 70m DSN, and other sources. This requires Ford, Brandt, Weadon, Hunter, and some outside help.

Interlock upgrade (John)

  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
    • Design well underway, pre-shutdown construction already planned
    • Ford and Weadon (mostly Weadon) need to coordinate shutdown work with Norrod and Anderson

Holography system (Todd)

  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
  • Need to process moon and calibrator beam cuts to characterize length scales of surface errors

  • We need to ask/work with Fred Schwab to compare the amplitude profiles from the old traditional holography data with the expected beam profile of the GBT with a 350um rms (random) surface. This is to see if the S/N was close to what would be necessary to see the effect at this level. I've asked him to pull out his old notes on this in anticipation of further work along these lines.

  • Investigate the holography possibilities (Todd?)
      • do background research on existing system
      • need to do some quick S/N calculations just to ensure this is worthwhile
      • could ressurect old system but would need to solve ease-of-use issues
      • decide whether to stick with old system or switch to new system early in summer shutdown
      • need to confirm useful adjustment can be made (actuators versus relative panel at corners)

OOF holography system (Richard)

  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see OOFDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Need to get moving on Goddard OOF collaboration
  • Need to test (or complete) Bojan's script pathway for analyzing Ka-band OOF scans into surface maps

LRF system (instrument development and system architecture) (Steve)

    • Investigate the constellation required for LRF to work. (F. Schwab?)
    • instrument development
    • surface measurement system
    • pointing (elevation axle pose) system

  • Someone to host and provide info to FAST team in March - John
  • Need to respond to Paul Goldsmith similar request - John
  • Simon Radford told me he could put me in touch with the JPL laser-ranging folks if we so desire.
  • In general, need someone to be the spokesperson for future rangefinder work. - John
  • Need to come up with a system architecture for future use of rangefinders - any use at all? Should have a brainstorming session with a wide variety of attendees.
  • Rangefinder patent.

Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (Todd)

  • Investigate instrumentation for wind measurements.
    • We should wait for Kim's analysis to proceed a bit further before going off with this task.
  • Have Jason/JD install pyrgeometer and compare to Operator's cloud cover log (Todd)
  • Misc instrument work:
    • Tipper
    • Phase Interferometer
    • Pyrgeometer
    • Optical pointing camera
    • What else...
  • Need to follow up on the effects seen by Todd, e.g. the inclinometer "wiggles" during beamswitches
  • Follow up on "hysteresis"
  • More generally, need to track down and fix all causes of tracking error Perhaps as a first step, we should try to implement a quantitative number (derived from QD,inclinometers,accelerometers) that expresses the overall level of vibration in real-time to the observer or operator screen.

Photogrammetry (John)

>
>

New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)

This task is to complete design and implementation of a new analysis package for a new pointing model.
Added:
>
>

Antenna characterization and commissioning (Frank)

Coordinate and perform commissioning and characterization observations

Servo Improvements (John)

This task is to improve the performance of the GBT's servos. It includes short- and long-term improvements

Interlock upgrade (John)

This task is to replace the interlock system on the GBT with a PLC-based system for better maintainability.

Holography system (Todd)

This task is to investigate and implement, if appropriate, a traditional Holography system for the GBT surface measurement.

OOF holography system (Richard)

This task is to coordinate efforts on doing OOF measurements on the GBT

LRF system (instrument development and system architecture) (John)

Coordinate the Laser Rangefinder System developments

Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (Todd)

Coordinate development of other miscellaneous PTCS instruments such as tippers, interferometers, etc.

Photogrammetry (John)

Coordinate the efforts to measure the surface with photogrammetry

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.13 - 19 Jan 2007 - RichardPrestage)
Added:
>
>

We (John, Todd, Richard) will add timescales before January 30th project meeting

Plan for a PTCS project group meeting week starting February 12th

Changed:
<
<

  • We should have a mini In-Progress Review (when?) to review this plan with the wider project group, and perhaps a few knowledeable outsiders. This should be rather informal however.
>
>

We should have a mini In-Progress Review (when?) to review this plan with the wider project group, and perhaps a few knowledeable outsiders. This should be rather informal however.

Work packages:

Changed:
<
<

  • I (RMP) think we should re-define our work packages, and start one wiki page per work package, with a clearly defined group leader for each one, who is responsible for keeping it up to date. Packages might be:
    • Antenna characterization and commissioning (name...)
      • pointing model
>
>

  • New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)
  • Antenna characterization and commissioning (Frank)
    • pointing runs
Changed:
<
<

    • Servo Improvements
    • Interlock upgrade
    • New holography system
    • LRF system (instrument development and system architecture)
    • Ancillary metrology instrumentation
    • Anything else?
>
>

  • Servo Improvements (John)
  • Interlock upgrade (John)
  • Holography system (Todd)
  • LRF system (instrument development and system architecture) (Steve)
    • instrument development
    • surface measurement system
    • pointing (elevation axle pose) system
  • Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (Todd)
    • Tipper
    • Phase Interferometer
    • Pyrgeometer
    • Optical pointing camera
    • What else...
  • Photogrammetry (John)
Changed:
<
<

    • Intermediate goal (Winter 2008/09) is to provide usable performance at 86 GHz for the Penn Array (the fully-sampled array receiver has less stringent pointing/tracking requirements than a single-pixel heterodyne receiver)
>
>

    • Intermediate goal (Winter 2008/09) is to provide usable performance at 86 GHz for the Penn Array (the fully-sampled array receiver has less stringent pointing/tracking requirements than a single-pixel heterodyne receiver) - see MustangEngSpecs
Changed:
<
<

  • Develop and deploy new traditional holography system by August 2007? Is this even conceivable?
  • In my (RMPs) opinion, system architecture of LRF V2 should be lower priority for now.
>
>

  • Characterize surface error length scales via moon or bright calibrator scans.
  • (Possibly Develop and deploy traditional holography system (existing or new during summer shutdwon, depending on investigations by Todd)
  • LRF Investigations:
    • Steve to find "knee in the curve" of current rangefinger performance (early spring)
    • Brainstorm potential surface measurement configurations
    • have Fred Schwab convert these to specific performance requirements
Changed:
<
<

The tasks from last year linger on! We are making progress on them, but they have yet to come to fruition.

  • Maintain PTCS Instrumentation in state of readiness: active surface, temperature sensors (structural and air), weather stations.
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system
>
>

New Pointing Analysis Package (Todd)

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see PointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Confirm Kim is now responsible for processing inclinometry data
  • assume new analysis package is matlab for now, may reassess later.

* Need to significantly re-engineer the antenna manager to do correct upstream co-ordinate conversions including both the actual subreflector position and the quadrant detector indications (any other indications. Do we do this now, or after some big system redesign?

Antenna characterization and commissioning (Frank)

  • co-ordinate execution of pointing runs, servo tests, etc.
  • Need to get wiki commissioning history up to date
  • Need to really check the quality of our mapping. Make a fully sampled beam map of a Condon double, after peaking up on a calibrator say five degrees away. Check how well the observed J2000 positions of both doubles match predicted. I think this is quite a high priority task; to my knowledge GBT staff have never really checked this. Write up as a project note.

Servo Improvements (John)

Changed:
<
<

      • Begin investigation on why this does not work. Requires Ford, Brandt, Hunter, Weadon
>
>

      • Begin investigation on why smooth trajectory does not translate into smooth antenna motion. Requires Ford, Brandt, Hunter, Weadon
Changed:
<
<

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see PointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see OOFDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
    • Investigate the constellation required for LRF to work. (F. Schwab?)
    • Investigate the holography possibilities (Todd?)
    • Investigate the photogrammetry possibilities. (F. Schwab?)
>
>

Interlock upgrade (John)

Added:
>
>

Holography system (Todd)

  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
  • Need to process moon and calibrator beam cuts to characterize length scales of surface errors

  • We need to ask/work with Fred Schwab to compare the amplitude profiles from the old traditional holography data with the expected beam profile of the GBT with a 350um rms (random) surface. This is to see if the S/N was close to what would be necessary to see the effect at this level. I've asked him to pull out his old notes on this in anticipation of further work along these lines.

  • Investigate the holography possibilities (Todd?)
      • do background research on existing system
      • need to do some quick S/N calculations just to ensure this is worthwhile
      • could ressurect old system but would need to solve ease-of-use issues
      • decide whether to stick with old system or switch to new system early in summer shutdown
      • need to confirm useful adjustment can be made (actuators versus relative panel at corners)

OOF holography system (Richard)

  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see OOFDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Need to get moving on Goddard OOF collaboration
  • Need to test (or complete) Bojan's script pathway for analyzing Ka-band OOF scans into surface maps

LRF system (instrument development and system architecture) (Steve)

    • Investigate the constellation required for LRF to work. (F. Schwab?)
    • instrument development
    • surface measurement system
    • pointing (elevation axle pose) system

  • Someone to host and provide info to FAST team in March - John
  • Need to respond to Paul Goldsmith similar request - John
  • Simon Radford told me he could put me in touch with the JPL laser-ranging folks if we so desire.
  • In general, need someone to be the spokesperson for future rangefinder work. - John
  • Need to come up with a system architecture for future use of rangefinders - any use at all? Should have a brainstorming session with a wide variety of attendees.
  • Rangefinder patent.

Ancillary PTCS instrumentation (Todd)

Added:
>
>

  • Have Jason/JD install pyrgeometer and compare to Operator's cloud cover log (Todd)
  • Misc instrument work:
    • Tipper
    • Phase Interferometer
    • Pyrgeometer
    • Optical pointing camera
    • What else...
  • Need to follow up on the effects seen by Todd, e.g. the inclinometer "wiggles" during beamswitches
  • Follow up on "hysteresis"
  • More generally, need to track down and fix all causes of tracking error Perhaps as a first step, we should try to implement a quantitative number (derived from QD,inclinometers,accelerometers) that expresses the overall level of vibration in real-time to the observer or operator screen.

Photogrammetry (John)

Changed:
<
<

Richard's Thoughts

>
>

Miscellaneous Things To Do:

Changed:
<
<

I'll get them down here first, then we can move them to the correct place

>
>

Capture thoughts here, then we can transfer them to the appropriate place.

Deleted:
<
<

  • Need "real-time" OOF for quick compensation of thermal surface deformations; compliments whatever small-scale technique we come up with
Changed:
<
<

  • Need to process moon and calibrator beam cuts to characterize length scales of surface errors
  • Aim to have a new holography system in place to do measurements in August/September, when we might have lots of telescope time. Is this realistic?
  • Need to get moving on Goddard OOF collaboration
  • Someone to host and provide info to FAST team in March
  • Need to respond to Paul Goldsmith similar request
  • In general, need someone to be the spokesperson for future rangefinder work.
  • Need to come up with a system architecture for future use of rangefinders - any use at all? Should have a brainstorming session with a wide variety of attendees.
  • Rangefinder patent.
  • Need to complete current servo upgrades, and convert them to production use
  • Need to follow up on the effects seen by Todd, e.g. the inclinometer "wiggles" during beamswitches
  • Follow up on "hysteresis"
  • More generally, need to track down and fix all causes of tracking error
  • Is drift-scan pointing worth following up on? I think it is, but we should make sure.
    • Do normal peaks to get us close
    • Explore az and el independently (easier to find sources that way)
    • start with az at transit, so it is also RA.
    • write a routine which will allow the antenna to scan in the direction of sidereal motion (could use PySlalib?)
    • run "drift scan" peaks in that direction, and "scanning" peaks in that direction. Simply look for offsets in time from when peak signal is seen - essentially an RA offset.
    • interleave drift scan peaks and tracking peaks in succession as a source transits, to look for repeatability
    • if we find an error in azimuth (e.g. a timing error), correct the same effect in elevation.
  • Need to significantly re-engineer the antenna manager to do correct upstream co-ordinate conversions including both the actual subreflector position and the quadrant detector indications (any other indications. Do we do this now, or after some big system redesign?
  • Need to really check the quality of our mapping. Make a fully sampled beam map of a Condon double, after peaking up on a calibrator say five degrees away. Check how well the observed J2000 positions of both doubles match predicted. I think this is quite a high priority task; to my knowledge GBT staff have never really checked this. Write up as a project note.
  • Need to finally come off the fence and ressurrect or abandon tipper, phase interferometer, prygeometer or modern equivalents thereof. Need to consult with an "atmospheric monitoring expert"? Is Todd one? Simon Radford?

>
>

  • Who will/will we present at URSI?
    • Kim (Pointing)
    • John (servo)
    • Ron/Roger (baselines)
Deleted:
<
<


Todd's Thoughts

  • Need to test (or complete) Bojan's script pathway for analyzing Ka-band OOF scans into surface maps
  • We need to ask/work with Fred Schwab to compare the amplitude profiles from the old traditional holography data with the expected beam profile of the GBT with a 350um rms (random) surface. This is to see if the S/N was close to what would be necessary to see the effect at this level. I've asked him to pull out his old notes on this in anticipation of further work along these lines.
  • During high-frequency observations, we should consider requiring a delay before starting the first scan after slewing to a pointing source to let mechanical oscillations settle. Perhaps as a first step, we should try to implement a quantitative number (derived from QD,inclinometers,accelerometers) that expresses the overall level of vibration in real-time to the observer or operator screen.
  • Need to decide on the mathematical package/infrastructure that will be used to implement Kim's final model at Green Bank. Matlab? Mathematica? Python(Numeric)?
  • Simon Radford told me he could put me in touch with the JPL laser-ranging folks if we so desire.
  • He believes traditional holo at ~12GHz cannot reach the desired level for CCAT, which wants 10um rms and would require ~3um measurement precision (1 part in 10000, or 0.036 degree phase). But from what I can tell, he has not done a full S/N calculation.

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.12 - 19 Jan 2007 - ToddHunter)
Added:
>
>


Todd's Thoughts

  • Need to test (or complete) Bojan's script pathway for analyzing Ka-band OOF scans into surface maps
  • We need to ask/work with Fred Schwab to compare the amplitude profiles from the old traditional holography data with the expected beam profile of the GBT with a 350um rms (random) surface. This is to see if the S/N was close to what would be necessary to see the effect at this level. I've asked him to pull out his old notes on this in anticipation of further work along these lines.
  • During high-frequency observations, we should consider requiring a delay before starting the first scan after slewing to a pointing source to let mechanical oscillations settle. Perhaps as a first step, we should try to implement a quantitative number (derived from QD,inclinometers,accelerometers) that expresses the overall level of vibration in real-time to the observer or operator screen.
  • Need to decide on the mathematical package/infrastructure that will be used to implement Kim's final model at Green Bank. Matlab? Mathematica? Python(Numeric)?
  • Simon Radford told me he could put me in touch with the JPL laser-ranging folks if we so desire.
  • He believes traditional holo at ~12GHz cannot reach the desired level for CCAT, which wants 10um rms and would require ~3um measurement precision (1 part in 10000, or 0.036 degree phase). But from what I can tell, he has not done a full S/N calculation.

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.11 - 19 Jan 2007 - RichardPrestage)
Added:
>
>


  • We should have a mini In-Progress Review (when?) to review this plan with the wider project group, and perhaps a few knowledeable outsiders. This should be rather informal however.

  • I (RMP) think we should re-define our work packages, and start one wiki page per work package, with a clearly defined group leader for each one, who is responsible for keeping it up to date. Packages might be:
    • Antenna characterization and commissioning (name...)
      • pointing model
      • OOF holography
      • tracking effects / improvements
    • Servo Improvements
    • Interlock upgrade
    • New holography system
    • LRF system (instrument development and system architecture)
    • Ancillary metrology instrumentation
    • Anything else?
Added:
>
>

Long Term Goals

  • See Refined Scientific Requirements for the PTCS by Jim Condon, and especially table 1.
    • Ultimate goal (Winter 2010/11) is to provide acceptable performance at 115 GHz.
    • Intermediate goal (Winter 2008/09) is to provide usable performance at 86 GHz for the Penn Array (the fully-sampled array receiver has less stringent pointing/tracking requirements than a single-pixel heterodyne receiver)
    • Near-term goal (Winter 2007/08) is to provide good performance at Q-band (52GHz), and explicitly to widen as much as possible then environmental envelope within which this performance can be delivered.
Changed:
<
<

Goals

>
>


Near-term Goals

Added:
>
>

  • Complete campaign of antenna characterization commissioning exercises
  • Develop and deploy new traditional holography system by August 2007? Is this even conceivable?
  • In my (RMPs) opinion, system architecture of LRF V2 should be lower priority for now.
Added:
>
>


Richard's Thoughts

I'll get them down here first, then we can move them to the correct place

  • Need "real-time" OOF for quick compensation of thermal surface deformations; compliments whatever small-scale technique we come up with
  • Email Simon Radford to consider OOF for CCAT
  • Need to process moon and calibrator beam cuts to characterize length scales of surface errors
  • Aim to have a new holography system in place to do measurements in August/September, when we might have lots of telescope time. Is this realistic?
  • Need to get moving on Goddard OOF collaboration
  • Someone to host and provide info to FAST team in March
  • Need to respond to Paul Goldsmith similar request
  • In general, need someone to be the spokesperson for future rangefinder work.
  • Need to come up with a system architecture for future use of rangefinders - any use at all? Should have a brainstorming session with a wide variety of attendees.
  • Rangefinder patent.
  • Need to complete current servo upgrades, and convert them to production use
  • Need to follow up on the effects seen by Todd, e.g. the inclinometer "wiggles" during beamswitches
  • Follow up on "hysteresis"
  • More generally, need to track down and fix all causes of tracking error
  • Is drift-scan pointing worth following up on? I think it is, but we should make sure.
    • Do normal peaks to get us close
    • Explore az and el independently (easier to find sources that way)
    • start with az at transit, so it is also RA.
    • write a routine which will allow the antenna to scan in the direction of sidereal motion (could use PySlalib?)
    • run "drift scan" peaks in that direction, and "scanning" peaks in that direction. Simply look for offsets in time from when peak signal is seen - essentially an RA offset.
    • interleave drift scan peaks and tracking peaks in succession as a source transits, to look for repeatability
    • if we find an error in azimuth (e.g. a timing error), correct the same effect in elevation.
  • Need to significantly re-engineer the antenna manager to do correct upstream co-ordinate conversions including both the actual subreflector position and the quadrant detector indications (any other indications. Do we do this now, or after some big system redesign?
  • Need to really check the quality of our mapping. Make a fully sampled beam map of a Condon double, after peaking up on a calibrator say five degrees away. Check how well the observed J2000 positions of both doubles match predicted. I think this is quite a high priority task; to my knowledge GBT staff have never really checked this. Write up as a project note.
  • Need to finally come off the fence and ressurrect or abandon tipper, phase interferometer, prygeometer or modern equivalents thereof. Need to consult with an "atmospheric monitoring expert"? Is Todd one? Simon Radford?

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.10 - 17 Jan 2007 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

Overview of work planned during Spring/Summer 2006

This spring will be used to get the project started back up. This process includes revisiting the project notes and other documentation, getting the project team together, and embarking on an initial course of action. Some specific items to start working on are detailed below in the task list.

>
>

Overview of work planned during Spring/Summer 2007

Added:
>
>

We have several projects in the works.

  • Improved pointing models incorporating explicit track measurements via inclinometers.
  • Servo improvements
  • Servo interlock system ( not strictly PTCS, but the same group of people are working on it
  • LRF Version 2 work
  • Data processing supporting new pointing models.
Changed:
<
<

Task List

>
>

Status of Task List from 2006

Added:
>
>

    • Accomplished.
Added:
>
>

    • Accomplished
Added:
>
>

    • Work on LRF originally slated to be used here is ongoing
Added:
>
>

      • It seems that the trajectory generation is not the problem. Rather, the response of the servo to the trajectory is poor.
Added:
>
>

      • Friction Compensation seems to drastically improve this. We are continuing to test this.
Added:
>
>

    • Underway
Added:
>
>

    • Underway
Added:
>
>

    • Underway
Added:
>
>

    • Underway
Added:
>
>

    • Not yet started

2007 Task List

The tasks from last year linger on! We are making progress on them, but they have yet to come to fruition.
  • Maintain PTCS Instrumentation in state of readiness: active surface, temperature sensors (structural and air), weather stations.
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system
  • Servo investigations and improvements
    • Trajectory generation
      • Begin investigation on why this does not work. Requires Ford, Brandt, Hunter, Weadon
    • Tracking at low azimuth rates
      • Finish this off by 2/28/07 Requires Ford, Brandt, Hunter, Weadon
    • Start a new servo system design
      • I think that we do need to redesign the servo. We can pull information from the LMT, 70m DSN, and other sources. This requires Ford, Brandt, Weadon, Hunter, and some outside help.
Added:
>
>

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see PointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see OOFDevelopmentFall2006
    • Finish this off.
  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
    • Investigate the constellation required for LRF to work. (F. Schwab?)
    • Investigate the holography possibilities (Todd?)
    • Investigate the photogrammetry possibilities. (F. Schwab?)
  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
    • Design well underway, pre-shutdown construction already planned
    • Ford and Weadon (mostly Weadon) need to coordinate shutdown work with Norrod and Anderson
  • Investigate instrumentation for wind measurements.
    • We should wait for Kim's analysis to proceed a bit further before going off with this task.
Deleted:
<
<

  • Resurrect quadrant detector and integrate into M&C for logging data in standard format
    • Jason Ray, J.D. Nelson, John Ford,SDD
Changed:
<
<

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, Rick Fisher
>
>

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, Todd Hunter
Changed:
<
<

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, John Ford, Rick Fisher
>
>

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, John Ford, Todd Hunter
Changed:
<
<

    • Frank Ghigo, Ron Grider
>
>

    • Frank Ghigo, Ron Grider, Todd Hunter
Changed:
<
<

    • Fred Schwab, John Ford, Dennis Egan, Harry Morton, Todd Hunter
>
>

    • Fred Schwab, Todd Hunter
Changed:
<
<

  • See attached proposed draft project schedule
>
>

  • See attached proposed OUT OF DATE draft project schedule

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.9 - 13 Dec 2006 - RichardPrestage)
Changed:
<
<

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see ContinuedPointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006?
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see ContinuedOOFDevelopmentFall2006?
>
>

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see PointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see OOFDevelopmentFall2006

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.8 - 09 Dec 2006 - RichardPrestage)
Changed:
<
<

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see ContinuedPointingFocusDevelopment?
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see ContinuedOOFDevelopment?
>
>

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see ContinuedPointingFocusDevelopmentFall2006?
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see ContinuedOOFDevelopmentFall2006?

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.7 - 13 Oct 2006 - RichardPrestage)
Changed:
<
<

Restarting the PTCS Project

>
>

PTCS Project Plan

Changed:
<
<

This is intended to be the top-level page providing an overview, and links to work related to restarting the PTCS. We are going to start working at a low level to improve pointing and collimation, as well as static measurements and corrections to small-scale surface accuracy.

>
>

This is intended to be the top-level page providing an overview, and links to work related to continued PTCS development. We are going to start working at a low level to improve pointing and collimation, as well as static measurements and corrections to small-scale surface accuracy.

Changed:
<
<

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing and OOF models
  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
>
>

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models, incorporate new techniques (e.g. inclinometer measurements of track) - see ContinuedPointingFocusDevelopment?
  • Bring someone up to speed on OOF models; start incorporating new techniques including JWST Wavefront Sensing and Controls Group collaboration - see ContinuedOOFDevelopment?
Added:
>
>

  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
Changed:
<
<

    • ???
>
>

    • Frank Ghigo, Ron Grider
Changed:
<
<

    • Fred Schwab, John Ford, Dennis Egan, Harry Morton
>
>

    • Fred Schwab, John Ford, Dennis Egan, Harry Morton, Todd Hunter
Added:
>
>

%META:TOPICMOVED{by="RichardPrestage" date="1160752481" from="PTCS.PTCSRestartProposal" to="PTCS.PTCSProjectPlan"}%


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.6 - 12 Jul 2006 - JohnFord)
Added:
>
>

  • main.mpp: Project Schedule for PTCS development

%META:FILEATTACHMENT{name="main.mpp" attr="" comment="Project Schedule for PTCS development" date="1152727723" path="main.mpp" size="278528" user="JohnFord" version="1.1"}%


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.5 - 10 Jul 2006 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

Overview of work planned during Spring 2006

>
>

Overview of work planned during Spring/Summer 2006

Changed:
<
<

This spring will be used to get the project started back up. This process includes revisiting the project notes and other documentation, getting the project team together, and embarking on an initial course of action.

>
>

This spring will be used to get the project started back up. This process includes revisiting the project notes and other documentation, getting the project team together, and embarking on an initial course of action. Some specific items to start working on are detailed below in the task list.

Added:
>
>

  • See attached proposed draft project schedule

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.4 - 10 Jul 2006 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade?)
>
>

  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
Changed:
<
<

    • John Shelton, John Ford, RF engineer, Electronics Tech, Mechanical engineering
>
>

    • John Shelton, John Ford, Steve White, Electronics Tech, Mechanical engineering
Changed:
<
<

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, Rick Fisher
>
>

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, John Ford, Rick Fisher
Changed:
<
<

  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade?)
>
>

  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade)
Changed:
<
<

    • John Ford, Tim Weadon, Dennis Egan, Harry Morton
>
>

    • Fred Schwab, John Ford, Dennis Egan, Harry Morton

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.3 - 23 Mar 2006 - JohnFord)
Changed:
<
<

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models
>
>

  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing and OOF models
Changed:
<
<

    • John Shelton, John Ford, RF engineer, Electronics Tech
>
>

    • John Shelton, John Ford, RF engineer, Electronics Tech, Mechanical engineering

 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.2 - 21 Mar 2006 - JohnFord)
Deleted:
<
<

Changed:
<
<

>
>

  • Improve pointing and collimation
    • Windy conditions
    • Thermally unstable conditions
    • Benign conditions
    • Improve servo performance
  • Measure and improve small-scale deformations
  • Make incremental improvements to PTCS instrumentation
Added:
>
>

This spring will be used to get the project started back up. This process includes revisiting the project notes and other documentation, getting the project team together, and embarking on an initial course of action.

Deleted:
<
<

  • Perform tacking performance experiment, for appropriate scanning patterns.
Added:
>
>

  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
  • Investigate instrumentation for wind measurements.
Changed:
<
<

    • jray,jnelson, 20% each
>
>

    • Jason Ray,J.D. Nelson
Changed:
<
<

    • jray,jnelson,jford,software person
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system
    • jshelton,jford,electronics tech
>
>

    • Jason Ray, J.D. Nelson, John Ford,SDD
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system (LRFV2)
    • John Shelton, John Ford, RF engineer, Electronics Tech
Changed:
<
<

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon
>
>

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, Rick Fisher
Changed:
<
<

  • Perform tacking performance experiment, for appropriate scanning patterns.
>
>

      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon, Rick Fisher
Added:
>
>

    • ???
Changed:
<
<

>
>

    • John Ford, Tim Weadon, Bob Anderson
  • Investigate measurements and adjustments for small-scale surface errors.
    • John Ford, Tim Weadon, Dennis Egan, Harry Morton
  • Investigate wind measurements for corrections.
    • John Ford, Jason Ray
Changed:
<
<

Commissioning Time Dates

>
>

Other Notes


 <<O>>  Difference Topic PTCSProjectPlan (r1.1 - 21 Mar 2006 - JohnFord)
Added:
>
>

%META:TOPICINFO{author="JohnFord" date="1142956690" format="1.0" version="1.1"}% %META:TOPICPARENT{name="InformationForProjectTeam"}%

Restarting the PTCS Project

This is intended to be the top-level page providing an overview, and links to work related to restarting the PTCS. We are going to start working at a low level to improve pointing and collimation, as well as static measurements and corrections to small-scale surface accuracy.


Goals


Overview of work planned during Spring 2006


Task List

  • Maintain PTCS Instrumentation in state of readiness: active surface, temperature sensors (structural and air), weather stations.
  • Resurrect quadrant detector and integrate into M&C for logging data in standard format
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system
  • Servo investigations and improvements
    • Trajectory generation
    • Tracking at low azimuth rates
  • Perform tacking performance experiment, for appropriate scanning patterns.
  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models
  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade?)


Possible Personnel Assignments

  • Maintain PTCS Instrumentation in state of readiness: active surface, temperature sensors (structural and air), weather stations.
    • jray,jnelson, 20% each
  • Resurrect quadrant detector and integrate into M&C for logging data in standard format
    • jray,jnelson,jford,software person
  • Begin design and development work on Elevation Axle Pose measurement system
    • jshelton,jford,electronics tech
  • Servo investigations and improvements
    • Trajectory generation
      • Fred Schwab, Joe Brandt, Tim Weadon
    • Tracking at low azimuth rates
  • Perform tacking performance experiment, for appropriate scanning patterns.
  • Bring someone up to speed on generating pointing models
  • Begin working on planning for work for track shutdown period (servo/controls upgrade?)


Commissioning Time Dates

-- JohnFord - 21 Mar 2006


Topic PTCSProjectPlan . { View | Diffs | r1.36 | > | r1.35 | > | r1.34 | More }
Revision r1.1 - 21 Mar 2006 - 15:58 GMT - JohnFord
Revision r1.36 - 07 Oct 2008 - 18:54 GMT - MartyBloss
Content copyright © 1999-2007 by the contributing authors.
All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.